Just talking about the concept is not enough, I combine Henan Mine Crane's experience in serving global customers, from 7 core technical dimensions, to give you a detailed comparison, to help you more intuitively see the difference between the two, to facilitate the subsequent selection.
Infrastructure Requirements
Infrastructure requirements, is one of the most core differences between the two, but also directly affects the initial investment cost of the project. Specific comparison is as follows:
| Factor | RMG | RTG |
|---|
| Rail foundation | Required | Not required |
| Civil work cost | Higher | Lower |
| Installation complexity | Higher | Moderate |
RMG requires the laying of specialized tracks, and the laying of tracks requires professional civil engineering, including foundation treatment, track installation, fixing, etc., which is not only costly, but also has a long installation period and higher complexity.
RTG, on the other hand, does not need tracks, as long as the yard floor is level and the load bearing is up to standard, it can be directly installed and used. The civil engineering is very simple, mainly consisting of ground compaction and leveling, which is of low cost, and the cycle of installation and commissioning is short, and it can be put into use in a few weeks usually.
Many global customers give priority to RTG in the initial investment stage, just because it can save a lot of civil construction costs and quickly realize the production. However, in the case of a large yard with a long-term fixed layout, although the civil construction cost of RMG is high, the stability and efficiency of long-term operation can offset the initial investment.
Mobility and Flexibility
Mobility and flexibility, directly affecting the operating range of the crane and the adaptability of the layout of the yard, specific comparisons are as follows:
| Factor | RMG | RTG |
|---|
| Movement | Fixed rail | Free movement |
| Yard layout change | Limited | Flexible |
| Repositioning | Difficult | Easy |
RMG's running track is fixed by the track, can only move horizontally along the track, longitudinal adjustment through the trolley, the operating range is fixed, cannot move at will. If the yard layout needs to be adjusted at a later stage, the track is difficult and costly to modify, and the flexibility is very limited.
RTG relies on tires to move freely within the yard, whether transverse, longitudinal, or turning, U-turn, are very flexible. Even if the layout of the yard is adjusted at a later stage, RTG can quickly adapt and re-plan the operation area without any infrastructure modification.
In short, if your yard layout is fixed and will not be changed for a long time, the fixed operation of RMG can ensure the accuracy of operation; if your yard is in the stage of expansion or the layout needs to be adjusted frequently, the flexibility of RTG will be more advantageous.
Stacking Density and Space Utilization
Stacking Density and Space Utilization directly determines the container storage capacity of the yard, especially for port yards with tight land resources, this is crucial.
RMG can achieve higher stacking density because it is guided by a fixed track with very high running accuracy, and the containers can be accurately aligned without offset when stacked. Normally, RMG can stack 6-8 layers of containers, and some large RMG can even stack more than 10 layers.
RTG, because it is moved by tires, will have slight shaking during operation, the stacking accuracy is not as good as RMG, and in order to ensure the safety of turning and moving, it is necessary to reserve a certain turning clearance, so the stacking density will be a little lower, and usually can stack 5-7 layers of containers.
For large ports with expensive land resources, the space utilization advantage of RMG is very obvious, which can store more containers on limited land and increase the throughput of the yard.
Automation Readiness
With the development of global smart ports, automation has become the development trend of container yards, the two cranes' automation readiness varies greatly, the specific comparison is as follows:
| Factor | RMG | RTG |
|---|
| Full automation | Highly suitable | Limited |
| TOS integration | Strong | Moderate |
| Remote operation | Common | Increasing |
The fixed rail design of RMG can accurately locate the running position of the crane, and it is easier to interface with the automation control system and terminal operating system (TOS) to realize fully automated operation. At present, most of the automated container terminals in the world choose RMG cranes, which can realize unattended and remote operation and significantly reduce labor costs.